Guy Mitchell (#1 in 1959), Johnny
Tillotson (#35 in 1965)
Heartache number one was when you left me
I never knew that I could hurt this way
And heartache number two was when you came back again
You came back and never meant to stay.
Now, I’ve got heartaches by the number,
Troubles by the score
Everyday you love me less, each day I love you more
Yes, I’ve got heartaches by the number,
A love that I can’t win
But the day that I stop counting,
That’s the day my world will end.
Heartache number three was when you called me
And said that you were coming back to stay
With hopeful heart I waited for your knock on the door
I waited, but you must have lost your way.